Catholic Vote Charity: Legit Or Scam?

is catholic vote a legitimate charity

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, a project of Fidelis, a Catholic organization; CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), which financially supports political candidates who align with Catholic social teaching; and CatholicVote.org Education Fund, a tax-deductible program. Charity Navigator, which rates charities based on accountability and finance, gives Catholic Charities a 100% score and a Four-Star rating, and Fidelis Center for Law and Policy a 92% score and a Four-Star rating. However, CatholicVote has been criticized for its political leanings, with some arguing that it exists to draw Catholic voters towards the Republican Party.

Characteristics Values
Nature of the organization CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States.
Relationship with the Catholic Church While CatholicVote acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium, it is independent of the Catholic Church.
Political leanings CatholicVote is a political action committee that aims to draw Catholic voters towards the GOP/Republican voter base.
Charitable status CatholicVote.org is a 501(c)4 organization. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, CatholicVote PAC, and CatholicVote.org Education Fund. The latter is a 501(c)3 tax-deductible program.
Ratings Charity Navigator gives Catholic Charities a 100% score and a Four-Star rating. CatholicVote.org has a 92% score and a Four-Star rating.
Transparency and accountability Charity Navigator evaluates charities based on metrics like conflict of interest policies, whistleblower policies, and document retention/destruction policies in their IRS Form 990.

cyfaith

CatholicVote.org's stance on same-sex marriage

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is independent of the Catholic Church, although it acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium. The group is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), and CatholicVote.org Education Fund.

CatholicVote.org has actively opposed same-sex marriage, arguing that its legalization would lead to negative consequences and a rollback of religious liberty. On June 25, 2015, the day before same-sex marriage became legal across the United States, CatholicVote.org uploaded a video titled "Not Alone," featuring Catholic individuals who opposed same-sex marriage. The video received significant backlash and was widely condemned as "anti-gay." Despite the criticism, CatholicVote.org stood by its message and urged parents to remove LGBT-themed books from libraries to shield children from such content.

In addition to their stance on same-sex marriage, CatholicVote.org has expressed concerns about the potential impact on society, religion, and family values. They have warned of a slippery slope leading to disastrous outcomes, including the normalization of polyamory and non-monogamous relationships. CatholicVote.org's position reflects a conservative interpretation of Catholic social teaching, and they actively support political candidates who align with their values.

cyfaith

CatholicVote's political leanings

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), and CatholicVote.org Education Fund. While CatholicVote.org acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium, it is independent of the Catholic Church.

The group's political action committee, CatholicVote PAC, aims to financially support political candidates who "will be faithful stewards of Catholic social teaching and the common good". In 2010, CatholicVote PAC made campaign contributions to six Republicans and one Democrat.

The website CatholicVote.org was first used by the Catholic Alliance, a grassroots group of Americans who agreed with the fundamentalist evangelical Protestant Christian Coalition's platform but wanted to include Catholics. The domain name was later owned by Larry Cirignano, the founder of Catholic Vote (later called Catholic Citizenship), who used it for six years until mid-2008.

Some sources claim that CatholicVote exists to draw Catholic voters towards the Republican Party. For example, they have posted articles challenging the Catholic Church's stance on the death penalty and immigration policies. Additionally, they have urged parents to check out any LGBT-themed books from their local libraries so that children cannot access them.

However, others argue that while CatholicVote leans conservative, it has not contradicted Catholic doctrine. For example, one source notes that an article argued the death penalty was not intrinsically evil, which is consistent with the Catholic Church's position that the death penalty is acceptable under certain circumstances.

cyfaith

CatholicVote's relationship with the Catholic Church

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), and CatholicVote.org Education Fund. While CatholicVote acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium, it is independent of the Catholic Church.

The group's political action committee aims to financially support political candidates who will be "faithful stewards of Catholic social teaching and the common good". In 2010, CatholicVote PAC contributed to the campaigns of six Republicans and one Democrat. The committee has been described as existing to draw Catholic voters into the Republican voter base. CatholicVote.org has also been accused of putting politics before Catholicism, with some claiming that it prioritizes issues such as abortion and same-sex marriage over Catholic teachings on the death penalty and immigration.

The CatholicVote.org Education Fund is a 501(c)3 tax-deductible program comprising two units: the CatholicVote.org Education Fund and the CatholicVote.org Legal Action Fund. The organization's domain name was first used by the Catholic Alliance in the early 2000s, which was a grassroots group of Americans who agreed with the fundamentalist evangelical Protestant Christian Coalition's platform but wanted to include Catholics. The domain was then owned by Larry Cirignano, the founder of Catholic Vote (later called Catholic Citizenship), until mid-2008 when it was operated by the Fidelis Center, which subsequently sold the domain to Fidelis, a related but independent 501(c)4 organization that operates the domain today.

CatholicVote.org has been criticized for its stance on same-sex marriage. On June 25, 2015, the day before same-sex marriage became legal across the United States, the organization uploaded a video to YouTube called "Not Alone," featuring Catholic people who oppose same-sex marriage. The video received a massive backlash and was condemned by many websites as "bigoted" or "anti-gay." In June 2022, CatholicVote.org urged parents to check out any LGBT-themed books from their local libraries to prevent children from accessing them.

cyfaith

CatholicVote's status as a charity

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, a project of Fidelis, a Catholic organization; CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), which financially supports political candidates who align with Catholic social teaching; and CatholicVote.org Education Fund, a tax-deductible program with two units: the CatholicVote.org Education Fund and the CatholicVote.org Legal Action Fund.

While CatholicVote.org acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium, it operates independently of the Catholic Church. The group has been described as having a conservative bias, with a focus on issues such as abortion and same-sex marriage.

Charity Navigator, an independent organization that evaluates charities, has given CatholicVote.org's parent organization, Fidelis, a 92% rating, earning it a Four-Star rating. This rating is based on accountability and finance, with Charity Navigator assessing factors such as conflict of interest policies, whistleblower policies, and financial integrity.

Catholic Charities, another Catholic-affiliated charity, has received a 100% rating from Charity Navigator, also earning it a Four-Star rating. This charity was founded over a century ago to care for orphans and is one of the largest and most comprehensive human services organizations in the United States.

cyfaith

CatholicVote's history

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, a project of Fidelis, a Catholic organization; CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), which financially supports political candidates who align with Catholic social teaching; and CatholicVote.org Education Fund, a tax-deductible program with two units: the CatholicVote.org Education Fund and the CatholicVote.org Legal Action Fund.

The history of CatholicVote dates back to the mid-1990s with the formation of the Catholic Alliance, a grassroots group of Americans who shared the fundamentalist evangelical Protestant Christian Coalition's platform but sought to include Catholics. The Catholic Alliance owned the CatholicVote domain name from its formation in 1995 until mid-2002. The domain was then owned by Larry Cirignano, the founder of Catholic Vote (later called Catholic Citizenship), from mid-2002 until mid-2008. In October 2008, the Fidelis Center began operating the domain, initially redirecting it to CatholicVote.com. The first articles published on the site were by co-founders Brian Burch and Joshua Mercer.

The Fidelis Center subsequently sold the domain to Fidelis, a related but independent 501(c)4 organization that operates the site today. On June 25, 2015, CatholicVote.org uploaded a video to YouTube titled "Not Alone," featuring Catholic individuals who opposed same-sex marriage. The video received a strong backlash and was widely condemned as "bigoted" or "anti-gay." In response, Brian Burch, the president of CatholicVote.org, highlighted the positive feedback they had received from those who felt their voices were being represented.

In recent years, CatholicVote has been cautioned by some members of the Catholic community for its perceived alignment with the Republican Party and its potential prioritization of politics over Catholicism. However, others have defended the organization, arguing that it has not contradicted Catholic doctrine and that its conservative leanings are within legitimate doctrinal boundaries.

Frequently asked questions

CatholicVote.org is a conservative, non-profit political advocacy group based in the United States. It is divided into three organizations: CatholicVote.org, CatholicVote.org Political Action Committee (CatholicVote PAC), and CatholicVote.org Education Fund. While it acknowledges the authority of the Magisterium, it operates independently of the Catholic Church. Charity Navigator gives Fidelis, the independent 501(c)4 organization that operates CatholicVote.org, a 92% rating.

CatholicVote.org describes itself as a community of patriotic Americans who believe that the Catholic faith's timeless truths are good for America. It aims to financially support political candidates who will be faithful stewards of Catholic social teaching and the common good.

Some people appreciate CatholicVote.org's firm pro-life stance and find their articles doctrinally sound and witty. However, others caution against sharing their articles, believing that the organization prioritizes politics over simple Catholicism and aims to rope voters into Republican candidates.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment