Catholics Advising: To Give Or Not To Give?

should a catholic give out advice

Advice is an important aspect of the Catholic faith. Catholics are encouraged to be active members of society and share their knowledge with others, as stated by Saint John XXIII. However, it is important to note that relying solely on the advice of others can sometimes be misleading, as faith is a personal and unique experience. While there is a wealth of advice available to new and existing Catholics, such as giving up meat on Fridays and praying during the elevation, it is also acknowledged that Catholics should not be limited to only giving what is required, as their journey of love and happiness is infinite. The Catechism, spiritual directors, and the Holy Spirit are recommended as sources of guidance when facing doubt.

Characteristics Values
Advice-giving approach Ask oneself "Why am I so eager to jump in with my two cents?" before giving advice
Love the person in the way God loves them
Help the person become who God intends for them to be
Align your desire for the person with God's desire for them
Ask the person who they think God wants them to be, then listen
Ask the person what qualities they want to be known for at the end of their life
Ask the person how they would act differently if they approached the problem in a way that aligned with their qualities
Consult the Catechism, a trusted spiritual director, or the Holy Spirit
Be active members of society
Share knowledge, exercise rights, fulfill obligations, and seek spiritual values
Do not separate religion from other aspects of life
Do not impose a veneer of monastic spirituality over secular lives
Do not let superior knowledge of the Catholic faith discourage or frustrate you
Do not impose your path on others
Do not expect Catholic life to be easy
Do not become a Sacristy Rat
Do not let the Church take the place of Jesus

cyfaith

Catholics should not limit themselves to giving religious advice

Catholics should not limit themselves to giving or seeking solely religious advice. While religion is a crucial aspect of a Catholic's life, it is not the only sphere of existence. Catholics are encouraged to be active members of society, which is essential to the fulfilment of the human vocation. This means that Catholics should engage with the world in various ways, including economically, politically, socially, and culturally.

Catholics can and should offer advice on a wide range of topics beyond strictly religious matters. For instance, Catholics can provide guidance on personal and interpersonal issues, such as navigating relationships, managing conflicts, or making life decisions. They can draw upon their religious values and principles while also recognising that faith is experienced differently by everyone, and religious beliefs have numerous interpretations.

Catholics are also well-positioned to offer advice on ethical and moral dilemmas. Their religious teachings can inform perspectives on right and wrong, justice, and virtue. For example, a Catholic may advise someone struggling with a moral dilemma by helping them reflect on the ethical principles derived from Catholic social teaching, such as human dignity, the common good, or solidarity.

Additionally, Catholics can give advice on spiritual matters that may not be exclusively tied to Catholic doctrine. They can share their experiences of prayer and meditation, or spiritual practices that promote personal growth and well-being. They can offer guidance on spiritual discernment, helping others recognise and respond to God's call in their lives, which may involve exploring different vocations or spiritual paths within the Catholic tradition.

Catholics should also be open to seeking advice beyond religious matters. They can benefit from guidance on personal development, emotional well-being, or practical life skills. By seeking advice, Catholics can enhance their overall well-being and become more effective in their personal and societal contributions. It is important to remember that while seeking advice, Catholics should not compromise their fundamental beliefs and values but rather use them as a foundation to navigate the advice they receive.

cyfaith

Advice-givers should be mindful of their motivations

To do this, you must first seek to understand who the person you are advising wants to be and what qualities they want to be known for. Only then can you help them become more fully the person God intends for them to be. This involves aligning your desires for the person with God's desires.

Additionally, it is important to remember that religious practices should not be confined to a separate sphere of life. As Saint John XXIII wrote, through human society, "in the bright light of truth, men should share their knowledge, be able to exercise their rights and fulfill their obligations, be inspired to seek spiritual values; mutually derive genuine pleasure from the beautiful, of whatever order it be." Therefore, when giving advice, it is crucial to consider the broader social, cultural, and political context in which the person is navigating their spiritual journey.

By being mindful of your motivations, seeking to understand the advisee's desires and aspirations, and considering the broader context, you can provide more thoughtful and effective advice that aligns with God's desires for the person.

cyfaith

Listening is a critical part of giving good advice

Listening is about actively processing and seeking to understand the meaning and intent behind the speaker's words. It involves understanding their emotions, perspectives, and experiences. By practising active listening and avoiding the temptation to give advice, we can better support those around us and foster healthier, more productive relationships.

Active listening is a communication skill that involves going beyond simply hearing the words that another person speaks. It requires being a mindful and focused participant in the communication process. It also gives them the time to say what they are thinking without trying to finish their sentences for them. Being patient involves not trying to fill periods of silence with your own thoughts or stories. It also requires listening to understand, not to respond. That is, don't prepare a reply while the other person is still speaking.

Before offering advice, it is important to ask, "Why am I so eager to jump in with my two cents?". Sometimes, it's less about them and more about us looking for some kind of personal ego boost. If we're living a Christ-centred life, our main motivation should be to love the person in the way God loves them. Our aim should be to help our friend or family member become more fully the person God intends for them to be.

When in doubt, Catholics can consult the Catechism, a spiritual director they trust, and, last but not least, the Holy Spirit Himself, who will undoubtedly give the best possible advice in living one's faith to the fullest.

cyfaith

Catholics should not impose their beliefs on others

The Catholic Church teaches that missionary activity is an act of charity, and Catholics are called to present the truth of the Christian faith to those who do not yet accept it. However, this does not mean forcing others to believe or conform to Catholic teachings. As Dr. Greg Popcak notes, a Christ-centered motivation for giving advice should be to love the person in the way God loves them, wanting their good.

Catholics can share their beliefs and give advice in a way that respects the freedom and dignity of the other person. This involves listening to the other person and asking them questions to help them discover their own path, rather than imposing a set of beliefs or rules on them.

Furthermore, the argument that one should not impose their beliefs on others is self-contradictory. By asserting that others should not impose their beliefs, one is imposing their own belief that imposition is wrong. This double standard undermines the very principle being advocated.

While Catholics should not impose their beliefs on others, they can and should share their faith and give advice in a way that is respectful and loving, always seeking the good of the other person.

cyfaith

Catholics should be active members of society

Catholics should strive to be active members of society, engaging with the world around them and seeking to make a positive impact. This is in line with the Catechism, which commands believers to be active participants in society, contributing to its development and cultural, economic, and social expressions.

Being an active member of society means more than just adhering to religious rituals or intellectual pursuits; it is about living out one's faith in the world. Catholics should seek to embody the teachings of Jesus Christ, serving the poor and needy, and being a force for good in their communities. This may involve volunteering, charitable work, or simply being a good neighbour and citizen.

Catholics can also engage with society by sharing their knowledge and wisdom with others. This can be done through teaching, mentorship, or simply having meaningful conversations with those around them. By sharing their insights and experiences, Catholics can help others navigate their own spiritual journeys and make sense of the world through a Catholic lens.

However, it is important to remember that faith is deeply personal, and there are many interpretations of religious beliefs. Therefore, when giving advice or sharing wisdom, Catholics should do so humbly and respectfully, recognizing that each individual's journey is unique. As Dr. Greg Popcak advises, before offering advice, one should examine their motivations and ask themselves if their motivation is pure and aligned with God's love for the person they are seeking to help.

Ultimately, being an active member of society is about living out one's faith in a way that honours Jesus Christ and contributes to the betterment of the world. Catholics are called to be a light in the world, and by engaging with society, they can help illuminate the path for themselves and others.

Frequently asked questions

Yes, Catholics are encouraged to be active members of society and share their knowledge. However, it is important to be mindful that faith is experienced differently by everyone and religious beliefs have numerous interpretations.

Before giving advice, it is important to ask oneself whether the motivation behind it is to love the person and help them become who God intends for them to be. Listening is also a critical part of giving good advice.

Catholics often remind themselves that their faith is not just a personal quirk or a set of ritual actions but Jesus Christ's plan to serve the poor and reach the world. Another common piece of advice is to not be afraid to seek advice from Catholic counsellors or spiritual directors.

New Catholics are often advised to find tour guides within the Church who can show them around but not impose their beliefs as the best or only path for everyone. They should also remember that Catholic life is not always easy as they are following someone who was persecuted and put to death.

Catholics should be cautious of advice that tells them to stick to religion and keep it restricted to private prayer spaces.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment