Irish Catholics: Loyal To King James Ii?

how did irish catholics view king james ii

James II, the last Catholic monarch of England, Scotland, and Ireland, was initially well-liked by the general public. However, his attempts to promote Catholicism and give civic equality to Catholic and Protestant dissenters led to conflict with Parliament and alienation among his subjects. Despite this, the Irish Parliament supported him, passing an Act for Liberty of Conscience that granted religious freedom to all and allowing him to build an army. James's attempt to regain the throne by invading Ireland ultimately failed, and he fled to France, never to return. While he was initially deserted by his Irish supporters, later historians argue that he and his successors played a central role as messianic figures for all classes in Ireland throughout the 18th century.

Characteristics Values
View of King James II James II was initially well-liked, but his conversion to Catholicism and attempts to promote the Catholic cause led to conflict with Parliament and alienated his subjects. He was ultimately overthrown in the Glorious Revolution and attempted to regain the throne by invading Ireland, but was defeated at the Battle of the Boyne. Despite this, some historians argue that he played a central role as a messianic figure for all classes in Ireland during the 18th century.

cyfaith

The Act for Liberty of Conscience

James II was the king of England, Scotland, and Ireland from 1685 until he was deposed in the Glorious Revolution of 1688-89. He was the last Catholic monarch of England, Scotland, and Ireland. James's placement of Catholic allies in high positions in the court and army, coupled with the birth of his son, alarmed the Anglican establishment. This led to him being overthrown and subsequently replaced by William III and Mary II.

James fled to Ireland, where he still had supporters, and attempted to reclaim his throne. At his urging, the Irish Parliament passed an Act for Liberty of Conscience, which granted religious freedom to all Roman Catholics and Protestants in Ireland.

However, it is important to note that James's efforts to establish religious freedom in Ireland were not solely driven by a commitment to liberty of conscience. He was also building an army in Ireland to reclaim his throne. Ultimately, he was defeated at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690 and fled to France, where he lived out the rest of his days. Despite his efforts to reclaim his kingdoms, James's desertion of his Irish supporters led to an unfavorable view of him in Ireland.

cyfaith

James' escape to France

James II was the last Catholic monarch of England, Scotland, and Ireland. He was deposed in the Glorious Revolution of 1688 and replaced by William III and Mary II. James's Roman Catholicism, as well as his attempts to create a centralised and bureaucratic state, led to his deposition. James's daughter Mary was declared Queen, ruling jointly with her husband, William.

James fled to France on 23 December 1688, after William landed in England on 5 November of that year. James's army deserted him, and he was captured in Kent while attempting to flee to France. He was released and placed under Dutch protective guard, and eventually allowed to escape.

James landed in Ireland in March 1689, attempting to recover his kingdoms. The Irish Parliament passed an Act for Liberty of Conscience, granting religious freedom to all Catholics and Protestants in Ireland. James worked to build an army in Ireland, but was defeated at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690 when William led an army to defeat him and reassert English control.

After his defeat, James fled to France once more, departing from Kinsale, never to return to any of his former kingdoms. He took up residence at the Chateau of Saint Germaine en Laye, on the outskirts of Paris, with his wife, supporters, and some of his children. James was granted a royal palace and a pension by Louis XIV, who had previously attempted to save him by warning the United Provinces that any action against James would be treated as hostility toward himself.

cyfaith

James' unpopularity

James II was initially well-liked, and his succession to the throne was peaceful. However, his unpopularity grew due to his attempts to promote Catholicism and his authoritarian governance.

James's unpopularity was driven by several factors, including his religious policies, his centralization of power, and his abandonment of his Irish supporters. James's conversion to Catholicism and his efforts to promote the Catholic cause alienated many of his subjects and led to conflicts with Parliament. He appointed Catholics to important positions in the military, government, and academia, which was seen as favouritism. James also attempted to grant religious freedom to Catholics and Protestants in Ireland, further contributing to his unpopularity among those who feared Catholicism.

The English and Scottish parliaments refused to pass measures that would undermine the primacy of the Protestant religion. James's prosecution of the Seven Bishops, who had petitioned the crown, was viewed as an assault on the Church of England and destroyed his political authority. His suspension of the Test Acts and establishment of a standing army led by Catholic officers caused further outrage.

James's attempts to centralize power and create a bureaucratic state apparatus provoked a hostile nationwide reaction. His intrusive governance and taxation clashed with alternative views that favoured a Dutch economic model and feared French power. James's deposition ultimately confirmed the primacy of Parliament over the Crown, ending political and civil strife.

James's flight to France and subsequent abandonment of his Irish supporters damaged his reputation. He became known in Ireland as "James the shit", and historians have since viewed him unfavourably in this regard. Despite his desertion, some historians argue that James played a central role as a messianic figure in Irish political poetry and culture throughout the 18th century.

cyfaith

The Battle of the Boyne

James II was a Roman Catholic whose attempts to Catholicise England had been deeply unpopular. He had also alarmed the Anglican establishment by placing Catholic allies in high positions in the court and army. In 1688, he was deposed by William of Orange, who established himself on the English throne as King William III. James fled to France but resolved to continue the struggle in Ireland, where he enjoyed strong support from the majority Catholic population.

William sailed from Cheshire and landed at Carrickfergus, County Antrim, on 14 June. He marched south towards Dublin, while James chose to make his defence on the River Boyne, around 30 miles from the city. William's forces reached the Boyne on 29 June, and the battle commenced on 1 July. William split his forces into three groups, which forded at Drybridge, Yellow Island, and Oldbridge. James initially ordered his men to fall back to gain more favourable ground, but upon seeing the movements of William's centre, he ordered a counterattack. Over a few hours, they were able to slow enemy advances and killed Schomberg, William's lieutenant. However, the Jacobites could not stop William's vastly more powerful army, and James ordered a withdrawal to Duleek.

James's army consisted mostly of raw recruits, including hastily trained and poorly equipped Irish infantry, many of whom were peasants who had been pressed into service. Some of them carried only farm implements such as scythes. In contrast, William's troops were generally far better trained and equipped. The best Williamite infantry were from Denmark and the Netherlands and were professional soldiers equipped with the latest flintlock muskets. William also had a large contingent of French Huguenot troops, as well as the highly effective irregular cavalry of Ulster Protestant "Enniskilliners".

cyfaith

James' legacy in Ireland

James II, the last Catholic monarch of England, Scotland and Ireland, left a complicated legacy in Ireland. Initially, he was well-regarded by the Irish Catholics. At his urging, the Irish Parliament passed an Act for Liberty of Conscience, which granted religious freedom to all Roman Catholics and Protestants in Ireland.

However, his legacy in Ireland was ultimately tarnished by his unsuccessful attempt to regain the throne. After being overthrown in 1688, James fled to France and then landed in Ireland in March 1689 with a troop of French soldiers. He attempted to build an army in Ireland to reclaim his kingdoms, but was defeated at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690 by William III, who led an army to defeat James and reassert English control. Following this defeat, James fled back to France, never to return to any of his former kingdoms, including Ireland. This desertion of his Irish supporters led to him being known in Ireland as "Séamus an Chaca" or "James the Shit".

Despite this negative perception, historians Breandán Ó Buachalla and Éamonn Ó Ciardha argue that James played a central role as a messianic figure in Ireland throughout the 18th century, with Ó Buachalla noting that "Irish political poetry for most of the eighteenth century is essentially Jacobite poetry".

Frequently asked questions

King James II converted to Catholicism in 1669. He attempted to give civic equality to Roman Catholic and Protestant dissenters, which led to conflict with Parliament.

King James II's placement of Catholic allies in high positions in the court and army, coupled with the birth of his son, alarmed the Anglican establishment. This led to the Glorious Revolution, which overthrew him and established Parliament as the ruling power in England.

After being overthrown, King James II attempted to regain his throne by invading Ireland with a troop of French soldiers. The Irish Parliament supported him and passed a bill punishing anyone acting against him, declaring him still to be king.

King James II was defeated at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690 by William III, who led an army to Ireland. Following his defeat, James fled to France and never returned to the British Isles.

King James II is generally regarded as an unpopular monarch, particularly in Ireland, where he is known as "James the Shit" due to his desertion of his Irish supporters. However, some historians argue that he played a central role as a messianic figure for all classes in Ireland during the 18th century.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment